REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
(based on 86 reviews)
Ratings Distribution
5 Stars
(63)
4 Stars
(13)
3 Stars
(7)
2 Stars
(2)
1 Stars
(1)
95%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Feels too small
Feels true to size
92% (71 reviews)
(71 reviews)
Feels too large
Feels too short
Feels true to length
99% (76 reviews)
(76 reviews)
Feels too long
91% (68 reviews)
(68 reviews)
Most Liked Positive Review
LOVE this
This is comfortable and sleek. I've been wearing it as a first layer underneath sweaters with wide necks, cardigans, etc., and it is a nice enough shirt that you can definitely have it...Read complete review
This is comfortable and sleek. I've been wearing it as a first layer underneath sweaters with wide necks, cardigans, etc., and it is a nice enough shirt that you can definitely have it showing. I was surprised that there's an elastic along the bottom of the shirt to sort of keep it in place, but fortunately it doesn't LOOK like it has an elastic bottom - it just looks like it fits well, and it stays in place.
VS
Most Liked Negative Review
super soft, but not perfect
I love the modal fabric because it's soft, stretchy and warm. This top would be perfect if it weren't for two design flaws:1. The taping in the shoulder seams is scratch...Read complete review
I love the modal fabric because it's soft, stretchy and warm. This top would be perfect if it weren't for two design flaws:1. The taping in the shoulder seams is scratchy. I have this top in black and smoke gray and for some reason the black one doesn't bother me, but the gray does.2. The elastic around the wrists and the hem is very narrow. If you push up your sleeves, it digs in a bit. Also, a narrow elastic on the bottom hem is fine for tucking in, but not flattering if you want to wear it untucked.
Reviewed by 86 customers
Sort by
Displaying reviews 1-15
Back to top
Previous | Next »
Excellent Service
By Joan
from WV
About Me Bargain Shopper, Career, Casual
Comments about Jockey No Panty Line Promise® Modal Scoop Neck Top:
Customer service was great and item was shipped to home efficently.
Should be heavier
By Stage Mom
from Studio City
About Me Bargain Shopper, Classic
Would be much better if it was warmer, the material is quite thin.
Rides up
By Modal Addict
from Ontario, Canada
I have two major fit issues with the long sleeve crew. I am a petite 5'3" and I find the waist rides up. As a result the crew becomes an uncomfortably tight crop top;) It doesn't stay tucked in or maintain an overlap with my Jockey modal long johns. This could be solved by 1. lengthening the long sleeve crew (it really is too short) and 2. relaxing the tight elastic bottom edge. The beauty of the no panty line promise panties is in their disappearing/non binding edges. Please carry this attribute over to your long sleeve crew.The colour choices vary from year to year. Please always offer modal thermal wear in neutral colours of tan, chocolate, black, navy and dark grey. You can see how popular jet grey was this year by the fact that it sold out in the size small. What about offering a richer colour like plum or burgundy instead of all those pastels?I am making the above suggestions because the long sleeve crew is so close to being amazing. The neckline is already perfect! It is not too low or too high but just right, especially with v-neck sweaters. Because the crew is smooth and body skimming, I can stylishly wear it under short-sleeve tees and blouses through the cooler months.
Very comfortable.
By Karla
from Albany, NY
About Me Bargain Shopper, Casual, Eclectic
I wear this shirt under EVERYTHING! It's very thin and the scoop neck allows me to wear it like a cami under other shirts and it looks nice. I bought the large, even though the sizing chart says I should be medium. I'm glad I did, as it's fitting but not too tight - it's not loose at all like I thought it might be. I really like how the shirt is long in the torso, so it doesn't ride up - I can stretch it over my belt line, or tuck it into my pants and it stays. (I'm 5'8") I also suggest the matching pants!
Just what I was looking for
By Steffie G
About Me Career
I wear it under sweaters to provide extra warmth, and as an accent.
Not as comfortable as expected
By Active Mom
from Waterford, CT
About Me Bargain Shopper
I use these tops under sweaters during the winter months. This was my first time purchasing the tops online as they are no longer available in stores. I ordered a navy blue top but the color is more of a purple. Additionally all of the tops have a raised seem on the left hand side that is most uncomfortable. I had to physically cut pieces of the seam away from each top in order to wear them. I find these garments to be a bit overpriced and would only purchase them on sale. They do functin well as an undershirt without being too bulky.
Comfort, warmth, and style
By Retired Joe
from Spotswood, NJ
Not for my use, but my wife's. She uses the tops under her RN uniform in the Hospital to help keep hher comfortable. She really likes everything about them. Thanks Jockey, you made ME look good!
Very Comfortable!
By Debbie
from Pittsburgh, PA
About Me Career, Casual
I love the feel and fit of these long john shirts. The only issue that I have is that the seams are scratchy. Regardless of how many times you wash them, they still scratch at the nect and on some, they scratch your wrist. I just wear them inside out and now, no scratching! They are great for keeping you warm and fit well under other tops.
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
Very soft
By reena
from Baltimore, MD
About Me Casual
This is great either on its own or as a layer. The material is just right as a thin layer that provides a lot of warmth.
great product!
By Lynette
from Ripon, CA
Great layering piece without the bulk.
(3 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
good thermal top
By David (yep its true) S
from oregon
I decided to give this a try as a thermal top layer. It fits me ok and i wear it underneath a t shirt for extra warmth at work in a cold warehouse. I have the matching black bottoms and the combo is terrific together! I love love love the micro modal fabric very soft and stretchy works good for me.
Service and delivery comments:
service and delivery excellent
Awesome top, I use it as my cami!
By Buzz
from Oakville, Ct
About Me Career, Sexy, Trendy
i love this top! I can wear it as a cami, which is awesome . I will be getting a few more in different colors. I now can wear dressy silks that I couldn't before because I couldn't find a long sleeve cami. I have silks in my closet that were never worn and now they are out of the closet and on me!
terrific
By Bucky
from New Hampshire
About Me Casual, Eclectic, Sexy, Trendy
great color and fit. Love the soft feel. very flattering fit.
Love this shirt!
By Barbarella9
from Las Vegas, NV
About Me Trendy
I buy these shirts to wear under my uniform at work. I wear them year round. They are super comfortable and wash well. Highly recommend!!
I love them!!
By Dianne
from Atlanta, GA
About Me Bargain Shopper, Casual, Classic
I wear them under my chef's uniform and for casual wear when it is cold out. Even when it warms up, I'm not too hot - it feels just right!All of this is the same for the Long Jane.